No excuses: Evening exercise doesn’t cause sleep problems

On I-95 at mile marker 124.4 in the County of Spotsylvania, motorists can expect potential delays due to a multi-vehicle accident. The north right shoulder is closed.

A study by Swiss researchers has destroyed a prime excuse for not exercising in the evenings. Contrary to popular belief, exercising before bedtime does not cause sleep problems unless the exercise is unusually strenuous.

It’s not just everyday couch potatoes who use the excuse that evening exercise will keep them awake, it’s also commonly believed by sleep researchers. But now scientists at the Institute of Human Movement Sciences and Sport at ETH Zurich have demonstrated it is not generally true.

The scientists combed through the literature on the subject and analysed all 23 studies that met their quality requirements. They concluded that doing exercise in the four hours before going to bed does not have a negative effect on sleep. “If doing sport in the evening has any effect on sleep quality at all, it’s rather a positive effect, albeit only a mild one,” says Christina Spengler, head of the Exercise Physiology Lab at ETH Zurich, in a news release.

The researchers combined data from the 23 studies and found that those who had exercised in the evening spent 21.2 percent of their sleeping time in deep sleep. For those who didn’t, the average figure was 19.9 percent. While the difference is small, it is statistically significant. Deep sleep phases are especially important for physical recovery.

IMAGE

IMAGE: Moderate intensity exercise shortly before bedtime does not negatively affect sleep. At most, vigorous exercise close to bedtime might have a negative effect. Each symbol in this overview represents one set of experimental data. 

Credit: ETH Zurich / Jan Stutz

An exception to the rule

Vigorous training within an hour before bedtime is a possible exception to the rule, although Spengler notes that the difference showed up in only one study and should be considered “preliminary.”

“As a rule of thumb, vigorous training is defined as training in which a person is unable to talk. Moderate training is physical activity of an intensity high enough that a person would no longer be able to sing, but they could speak,” Spengler says. One example of vigorous training is the kind of high-intensity interval training that competitive athletes often perform. In many cases, though, a longer endurance run or a longer ride on a racing bike would fall into the moderate training category.

The study found that those who completed an intensive training session shortly before bedtime took longer to fall asleep. The study also provided insight into why this is the case: the test subjects were not able to recover sufficiently in the hour before they went to bed. Their hearts were still beating more than 20 beats per minute faster than their resting heart rate.

Evening exercise is better than none

It’s always possible to find reasons not to exercise. But they don’t outweigh the potential benefits of exercise — a longer, healthier life. Sports physicians recommend at least 150 minutes of moderate exercise each week and the new study finds no reason not to exercise at night.

“People can do exercise in the evening without hesitation. The data shows that moderate exercise in the evening is no problem at all,” says Jan Stutz, a doctoral student in Spengler’s research group and lead author of the analysis, which was published in the journal Sports Medicine.

Moderate exercise did not cause sleep problems in any of the studies examined, not even when the training session ended just 30 minutes before bedtime. “However, vigorous training or competitions should be scheduled earlier in the day, if possible,” Stutz says.

Stutz and Spengler point out that they examined average values over the course of their analysis, which made only general statements possible. “Not everyone reacts to exercise in the same way, and people should keep listening to their bodies. If they notice they are having problems falling asleep after doing sport, they should try to work out a little earlier,” Stutz says.

“It is well known that doing exercise during the day improves sleep quality,” Spengler says, adding: “Now we have shown that, at the very least, exercising in the evening doesn’t have a negative effect.”

 

Comments

About the Author

Truman Lewis
A former reporter and bureau chief, Truman Lewis has covered presidential campaigns, state politics and stories ranging from organized crime to environmental and consumer protection.