Appeals Court Hears Arguments in Dulles Toll Road Case

October 2, 2012 8:11 pmBy: 
photo

The toll road on a light travel day

Is the Dulles Toll Road toll a toll? Or a tax? And who has jurisdiction to make the decision?

Those are among the questions being pondered by a three-judge panel of the U. S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in D.C., which today heard arguments from the group called “No Toll Increase.” The group has challenged the legality of using a portion of the tolls collected on the busy commuter highway to fund construction and operation of the Metro Silver Line.

The group’s attorney, Bob Sincar, argued before the panel that, under Virginia law, proceeds from tolls can only be used to fund construction and maintenance of the roads and bridges on which the toll is collected. He also argued that since the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority (MWAA), which owns the toll road and is building the Silver Line, is not an elected body it does not have the authority to impose a tax.

But the MWAA’s attorney, Stuart Raphael, said the tolls are clearly user fees, not a tax, since they only imposed on those using the road, not on those who choose to use other roads, take the train or stay home.  He argued that all the proceeds of the tolls are used within the Dulles transportation corridor, thereby benefiting everyone within the corridor.

A question that could derail the court’s deliberations is whether it has jurisdiction over the matter. One judge suggestion the case should be heard in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which includes Virginia.

The MWAA is an interstate compact. Its governing board is made up of representatives appointed by elected officials from Virginia, D.C., and the federal government. None of its members answers directly to voters and until recently, the board operated largely without oversight. It has since come under withering criticism for lavish spending, lax personnel policies and displaying a lack of concern to local citizens’ sensitivities.

Comments

More Top Stories

  • Top Stories Transportation Plans to toll I-66? Not so fast, say four NoVa Congressmen

    Plans to toll I-66? Not so fast, say four NoVa Congressmen

    There is rising opposition from Fairfax County residents to plans to add toll lanes and tighten HOV restrictions on I-66 outside the Beltway, as well as a growing feeling that Fairfax lives and property are somehow worth less than those in Arlington, which has choked off all but the merest trickle of traffic since I-66 opened. Today, four Northern Virginia congressmen warned Virginia Transportation Secretary Aubrey Layne not to move too fast with the controversial plans, saying they are deeply […]

    Read more →
  • Education Fairfax Top Stories Transportation GMU’s Campus Drive opens Saturday

    GMU’s Campus Drive opens Saturday

    By Buzz McClain George Mason University After four years of planning, design and construction, Campus Drive officially opens Saturday, April 18, with a day of celebration. The ceremony begins at 12:30 p.m. at the Field House on the Fairfax Campus of George Mason University. Mason president Ángel Cabrera will be joined in the ribbon cutting by state and local leaders who were instrumental in the road project, which was built with $15 million in state funds. The new road, which includes a traffic and pedestrian […]

    Read more →
  • Chantilly Top Stories Transportation Final milling and paving underway on Stringfellow Road

    Final milling and paving underway on Stringfellow Road

    Crews begin several weeks of final milling and paving today at the Stringfellow Road widening project in Chantilly. Milling begins today to tie in intersections at Fair Lakes Boulevard, Route 50 and streets between. Final paving will begin around April 17 and last through May 4. Drivers are encouraged to use alternate routes during the work, as there will be one lane closed in each direction daily, as well as intermittent intersection detours. All lanes will reopen each afternoon. Fairfax […]

    Read more →
  • Education Entertainment & Events Fairfax Top Stories GMU Center for the Arts announces 25th season

    GMU Center for the Arts announces 25th season

    Celebrating 25 years of bringing outstanding performing arts to George Mason University and audiences in the greater Washington, D.C. area, George Mason University’s Center for the Arts in Fairfax announces its2015-2016 Great Performances at Mason season, featuring a collection of renowned artists and ensembles from across the globe. The season begins in September 2015 and continues through May 2016. “Our 25th anniversary season continues to provide a remarkable variety of performing arts that both entertains and educates,” said Thomas Reynolds, […]

    Read more →
  • Real Estate Top Stories Fairfax March home sales spike on pent-up demand from long cold winter

    Fairfax March home sales spike on pent-up demand from long cold winter

    Northern Virginia home sales spiked 14 percent in March, setting the stage for what many hope will be a vibrant spring selling season. But the Northern Virginia Association of Realtors notes that the sales spike may be partly due to the unusually cold winter. “The 14 percent increase in home sales this past March is a trend to celebrate, however we must remember that the 2014 winter polar vortex cast a huge chill on early 2014 home sales,” said Mary Bayat, the […]

    Read more →
  • County Government Top Stories Listen — new Fairfax County noise ordinance in the works

    Listen — new Fairfax County noise ordinance in the works

    It’s been awhile since Fairfax County had a comprehensive noise ordinance, but that may not be the case much longer. The Board of Supervisors has a proposed new ordinance that will be open for public comment at a hearing tentatively set for May 12. The new rules cover everything from lawn mowers, barking dogs, loudspeakers at athletic fields, and industrial operations. Supervisors say they tried to balance the need to get things done with residents’ quality of life, limiting certain noises to […]

    Read more →
  • Business Politics Top Stories Virginia, D.C. file brief supporting Obama’s immigration actions

    Virginia, D.C. file brief supporting Obama’s immigration actions

    Virginia, the District of Columbia and 14 other states today filed an Amicus Brief in support of President Obama’s immigration actions. “I commend Attorney General Herring for joining 14 states and the District of Columbia in filing an amicus brief in support of President Obama’s immigration actions which allow undocumented workers who are living, working, and paying taxes in the United States to lawfully stay in this country. As the brief notes, these actions will have positive benefits to the Virginia […]

    Read more →
  • County Government Top Stories Op-Ed: Never let a good crisis go to waste

    Op-Ed: Never let a good crisis go to waste

    By Sharon Bulova Chairman, Fairfax County Board of Supervisors One of my favorite inspirational sayings comes from Winston Churchill: “Never let a good crisis go to waste.” I believe that when faced with a crisis, we must look for opportunities to make things better. This is advice I’ve been following since the Great Recession roiled the nation in 2008, followed by a sluggish recovery that has stalled over the Washington Metropolitan Region like a stubborn storm system. From December 2012 […]

    Read more →