Allen, Kaine Turn to Taxes in New Ads
The U.S. Senate race between George Allen and Tim Kaine has turned to taxes, with Kaine releasing a new ad that touts his record of “fiscal responsibility” while the Allen camp accuses Kaine of rewriting history.
Kaine’s new ad features fellow former governor and current U.S. Senator Mark Warner. “We were a great team in Richmond,” Warner says in the thirty-second ad as he walks in front of the capitol building in Richmond, saying that he and Kaine worked for more than a decade to improve business friendliness, recruit companies to the Commonwealth, invest in educating Virginia’s workers, and make tough fiscal decisions to balance the budget.
“And we’ll be a great team in Washington,” Kaine continues, arguing that both he Warner have endorsed a balanced, bipartisan approach to responsibly reduce the federal budget deficit that makes significant cuts but also leaves room for investments in education, infrastructure, and other key areas to grow the economy and create jobs.
But the Allen campaign takes issue with some of the claims.
“When Tim Kaine tries to take credit for cutting his pay, he forgets to mention he only cut it by 5 percent well into the second year of his term compared to Mark Warner’s 20 percent cut and George Allen’s 10 percent cut,” the Allen campaign said in a press release.
“Before there was Mark Warner or Tim Kaine, there was George Allen who set the example for them as the first Governor to cut his own pay by 10 percent,” said Emily Davis, spokeswoman for George Allen for U.S. Senate. “George Allen also reduced the size of state government by 9 percent, lowered taxes and helped Virginia create 300,000 jobs. That’s one example Virginians wish Tim Kaine had followed. Instead, he left Virginia with 100,000 jobs lost, closed rest stops, skyrocketing tuition, and a unanimously rejected budget containing tax hikes on people making as little as $17,000 a year.”
Allen, meanwhile, released a new ad asking what Allen said was the top issue on Virginians’ minds: will they still have a job if Washington continues to fail to do its job?
Problem solver
Throughout the campaign, Kaine has portrayed himself as a problem solver who works both sides of the aisle to control spending while making strategic investments in infrastructure and education.
“Tim is exactly the kind of problem solver we need in the U.S. Senate. Virginia made great strides under his leadership during the worst national recession in 70 years, winning accolades like Best State for Business, Best Managed State, and best state to raise a child,” said Warner. “I couldn’t be more proud to support Tim’s campaign and look forward to having his bipartisan approach in Washington to help tackle the challenges we face.”
Warring claims
It can be difficult for voters to make sense of the conflicting claims. To counter claims of distortion, each campaign issues the text of the ads, accompanied by supporting data.
Here is Kaine’s ad:
| Claim | Fact |
| KAINE: “As governor, I cut $5 billion in spending and balanced the budget every year.”[On-Screen: Tim Kaine CUT SPENDING BALANCED THE BUDGET] |
Richmond Times-Dispatch: “Kaine Worked With Legislators To Cut More Than $5 Billion…And Balance The Budget.” The Richmond Times-Dispatch reported, “Reeling from the downturn and faced with three years of revenue shortfalls, Kaine worked with legislators to cut more than $5 billion to offset dwindling revenues and balance the budget. Over his tenure, the state’s general fund dropped from $15.1 billion to $14.8 billion — or 2 percent, marking the first time in decades that the fund shrank during a governor’s term.” [Richmond Times-Dispatch, 10/7/12]AP: Kaine Cut Nearly $6 Billion And Balanced The Budget. The Associated Press reported, “While the recession depleted revenues, Kaine and the General Assembly cut nearly $6 billion and never finished a fiscal year with insufficient funds…” [Associated Press, 11/10/11] |
| WARNER: “And Tim Kaine and I both cut our own pay as governors to lead by example.”[On-Screen: Mark Warner BOTH CUT THEIR OWN PAY] |
Richmond Times-Dispatch: “Kaine Is Taking A 5 Percent Pay Cut.” [Richmond Times-Dispatch, 10/1/07]2007: Kaine Returned 5 Percent Of His Annual Salary. The Washington Times reported, “Mr. Kaine also plans to return 5 percent of his annual salary and defer pay raises to administration staffers.” [Washington Times, 10/2/07]
Daily Press: Warner “Valiantly Cut His Own Pay When He Trimmed The State Budget.” The Daily Press reported, “By statute, Warner is entitled to $124,854.96, but valiantly cut his own pay when he trimmed the state budget.” [The Daily Press, 3/26/04] |
| KAINE: “Mark Warner and I reached across party lines to get things done.” | Warner Worked With Republicans To Pass Record Investment In EducationWarner Worked With A Republican General Assembly To Pass The Largest Investment In K-12 Education In Virginia’s History. Washingtonian Magazine reported, “Education was a pet issue for Warner, one he pushed nationally as chair of the National Governors’ Association. His instate education reforms–which included the largest investment in K-12 education in Virginia’s history and the second-largest increase in college and university funding in the nation (after years of cuts)–allowed greater accountability and, he claims, helped lead to the nation’s highest SAT score increase in math.” [Washingtonian Magazine, February 2006]
Kaine Worked With Republicans To Pass A Record Higher Education Bond Package 2008: General Assembly Agreed to $1.4 Billion Bond Package For Higher Ed, Which Kaine Called “Critical to Our Economic Success.” The Bond Buyer reported, “Virginia lawmakers late Tuesday reached a preliminary agreement on a $1.4 billion bond package to fund construction at the state’s colleges, parks, and mental health facilities. . . . ‘The General Assembly has worked very hard over the last months to advance our higher education bond proposal,’ Kaine said in a statement. ‘The completion of their work will signal a record investment in Virginia’s higher education institutions, which are absolutely critical to our economic success.’” [The Bond Buyer, 4/17/08] Roanoke Times: $1.4 Billion Bond Package For Higher Education A Rare Moment To Be Proud Of All Lawmakers.In an editorial, the Roanoke Times wrote, “Rare is the moment when Virginians can look to Richmond and be proud of every single lawmaker. It’s been a long time coming, but just such an auspicious occasion occurred last week when all lawmakers agreed to a $1.46 billion bond package that, for the most part, will be spent bettering the state’s universities and community colleges.” [Editorial, Roanoke Times, 4/28/08] Kaine Worked With President Bush To Secure $900 Million In Federal Investment For Rail To Dulles 2009: Working With The Bush Administration, Kaine Secured Federal Funding For Rail To Dulles. According to the Washington Post, “U.S. Transportation Secretary Mary Peters gave the final federal seal of approval to plans to extend Metrorail to Dulles International Airport…ensuring that the $5.2 billion project can move forward without restrictions. […] ‘It’s an exhilarating feeling,’ said Virginia Gov. Timothy M. Kaine (D), who praised Peters and Northern Virginia’s congressional delegation for working together to keep the rail line alive. ‘It’s going to be a wonderful project for the whole region.’” [Washington Post, 1/8/09] Kaine Announced Signing Of $900 Million Funding Agreement For Dulles Rail Project. Kaine said the following in a statement on the signing of the Dulles Corridor Metrorail Project Full Funding Grant Agreement between the U.S. Department of Transportation and the MWAA: “One of my top transportation priorities has been to see Dulles Rail become a reality. The signing of the $900 million Full Funding Grant Agreement for Phase 1 of the project is an accomplishment that has taken more than 10 years to achieve and I am proud to have this honor.” [Kaine Administration Press Release, 3/10/09]
Kaine Worked With Republicans To Preserve Open Space Kaine’s Land Trust Program “Secured More Than 400,000 Acres” Of Land During His Gubernatorial Term.According to the Daily Press, “Tim Kaine, secured more than 400,000 acres during his four years as governor.” [Daily Press, 7/5/11] Kaine Worked With Republicans To Ban Smoking In Bars March 2009: Kaine Signed Into Law A Ban On Smoking In Bars And Restaurants. According to the Daily Press, Kaine “signed into law a statewide ban on smoking in restaurants and bars . . . The ban is a significant victory for Kaine in his final session in the executive mansion, and is likely to become a campaign trail issue this fall, when all members of the House of Delegates stand for re-election.” [Daily Press, 3/10/09] |
| WARNER: “We were a great team in Richmond.”KAINE: “And we’ll be a great team in Washington. I’m Tim Kaine and I approve this message.”
WARNER: “Because we’ll work together to restore our fiscal responsibility, grow our economy, and create jobs.” |
|
| MALE VOICE: “Tim Kaine—bringing people together to tackle the challenges of tomorrow.”[On-Screen: APPROVED BY TIM KAINE. PAID FOR BY KAINE FOR VIRGINIA.][On-Screen: KaineForVA.com KAINE U.S. SENATE] |
And here is Allen’s:
| Audio | Graphics | Verification |
|
AVO: “If Washington doesn’t do its job, will we still have ours?
|
|
ACCORDING TO THE AEROSPACE INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION, DEFENSE BUDGET CUTS PUT 207,571 VIRGINIA JOBS AT RISK
According To An Analysis Of “The Impact Of The Budget Control Act Of 2011 On DOD And Non-DOD Agencies,” Virginia Could Lose 207,571 Jobs Due To Budget Cuts. (Stephen S. Fuller, Ph.D., “The Impact Of The Budget Control Act Of 2011 On DOD & Non-DOD Agencies,” Goerge Mason University as Prepared for the Aerospace Industries Association, 7/17/12)
“Virginia Could Lose 207,571 Jobs And Nearly $10.7 Billion In Labor Income From Federal Spending Cuts Starting Next Year If Congress Fails To Resolve The Looming Budget Crisis, According To An Analysis Released Tuesday.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
“Big Hit” To Virginians. “‘It’s a pretty big hit’ for Virginia, said Stephen Fuller, an economist at George Mason University who conducted the analysis along with Chmura Economics and Analytics, a research firm in Richmond.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
Areas Hardest Hit Would Be Northern Virginia And Hampton Roads, But Whole State Would Feel The Ramifications. “In Virginia, the spending cuts likely would hit Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads the hardest because of the concentration of defense-related and federal contracting jobs in those areas. Still, the entire state would suffer losses, Fuller said.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
D.C. And Maryland Would Lose Jobs, Effecting Virginians Who Commute For Their Employment. “The impact on Virginia also could be larger than the direct job losses in the state, Fuller said. The District of Columbia and Maryland also would lose tens of thousands of jobs. They rank fourth and fifth overall in the number of jobs that would disappear.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
|
|
“Will our military still be strong?
|
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE SECRETARY LEON PANETTA WARNS BUDGET CUTS WILL LEAD TO SMALLEST GROUND FORCE SINCE 1940 AND SMALLEST NAVY SINCE WORLD WAR I
Panetta Warned Of “Dramatic Cuts.” “Defense Secretary Leon Panetta is warning that the deficit-reduction supercommittee’s failure to agree on a savings plan will force dramatic cuts to America’s nuclear arms, including the elimination of ground-based intercontinental ballistic missiles, cancellation or delays in plans to build a new strategic bomber, and cuts to missile submarine production.” (Tim Mak and Charles Hoshkinson, “Leon Panetta Paints Doomsday Scenario,” Politico, 11/15/11)
“The Drastic Budget Reductions Triggered By The Panel’s Failure Would Lead To The Smallest U.S. Ground Forces Since 1940 And The Smallest Navy Since The Beginning Of World War I, He Said Monday.” (Tim Mak and Charles Hoshkinson, “Leon Panetta Paints Doomsday Scenario,” Politico, 11/15/11)
“The Air Force And The Defense Department’s Civilian Workforce Would Shrink To Their Lowest Levels Ever.” (Tim Mak and Charles Hoshkinson, “Leon Panetta Paints Doomsday Scenario,” Politico, 11/15/11)
“Sequestration Will See The U.S. Military Shrink To The Smallest Ground Force Since 1940. A 230-Ship Navy Would Be The Smallest Fleet Since World War I, And The Air Force Would Have The Fewest Tactical Fighters In Its History.” (Gregory P. Keeley, Op-Ed, “Keeley: Perils of sequestration,” The Washington Times, 6/8/12)
|
|
|
“Tim Kaine supported last year’s debt deal
|
|
KAINE SUPPORTED THE DEBT COMPROMISE THAT CREATED THE FAILED SUPER COMMITTEE, LEADING TO SEQUESTRATION
Tim Kaine Supported The Debt Compromise, Which Created The Super Committee. “Former Gov. Tim Kaine, now a candidate for the U.S. Senate, declared his support for a compromise plan to raise the debt ceiling after the measure cleared the House of Representatives last night.” (Michael Sluss, “Kaine Backs ‘Flawed’ Debt Compromise, Dings Rivals,” The Roanoke Times’ Blue Ridge Caucus Blog, 8/2/11)
Kaine: “While Far From Perfect, The Current Approach Before Congress Maintains Economic Stability By Raising The Debt Ceiling And Enacts Important Spending Cuts That Will Help Preserve Our Nation’s And Virginia’s Credit Rating. This is the beginning of a much longer process as we work to rebuild our economy.” (Kaine For Virginia, “Kaine Statement On Debt Ceiling Compromise,” Press Release, 8/1/11)
Kaine: “I’ve Said All Along That Our Approach To Restoring Fiscal Responsibility Must Be Both Bipartisan And Balanced. By Establishing A Joint Committee With Representation From Both Parties That Is Empowered To Make Additional Cuts As Well As Raise New Revenue, Congress Has Said That They Also Want A Bipartisan And Balanced Result.” (Kaine For Virginia, “Kaine Statement On Debt Ceiling Compromise,” Press Release, 8/1/11)
|
|
“that will impose devastating defense cuts, threatening Virginia jobs.
|
RTD Headline: “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen” |
207,571 VIRGINIA JOBS AT RISK
According To An Analysis Of “The Impact Of The Budget Control Act Of 2011 On DOD And Non-DOD Agencies,” Virginia Could Lose 207,571 Jobs Due To Budget Cuts. (Stephen S. Fuller, Ph.D., “The Impact Of The Budget Control Act Of 2011 On DOD & Non-DOD Agencies,” Goerge Mason University as Prepared for the Aerospace Industries Association, 7/17/12)
“Virginia Could Lose 207,571 Jobs And Nearly $10.7 Billion In Labor Income From Federal Spending Cuts Starting Next Year If Congress Fails To Resolve The Looming Budget Crisis, According To An Analysis Released Tuesday.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
“Big Hit” To Virginians. “‘It’s a pretty big hit’ for Virginia, said Stephen Fuller, an economist at George Mason University who conducted the analysis along with Chmura Economics and Analytics, a research firm in Richmond.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
Areas Hardest Hit Would Be Northern Virginia And Hampton Roads, But Whole State Would Feel The Ramifications. “In Virginia, the spending cuts likely would hit Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads the hardest because of the concentration of defense-related and federal contracting jobs in those areas. Still, the entire state would suffer losses, Fuller said.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
D.C. And Maryland Would Lose Jobs, Effecting Virginians Who Commute For Their Employment. “The impact on Virginia also could be larger than the direct job losses in the state, Fuller said. The District of Columbia and Maryland also would lose tens of thousands of jobs. They rank fourth and fifth overall in the number of jobs that would disappear.” (John Reid Blackwell, “Virginia Stands To Lose 207,571 Jobs If Federal Budget Cuts Happen,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/18/12)
|
|
“George Allen opposed it.
|
SUPER: George Allen opposed the defense cuts. |
ALLEN OPPOSED THE DEAL BECAUSE IT THREATENED VIRGINIA JOBS
“Allen Said The Defense Cuts In The Deal Would Threaten Virginia Jobs.” (Chelyen Davis, “State’s Congressional Representatives Support Legislation,” The Free Lance-Star [Fredericksburg, Virginia], 8/2/11)
|
|
“Tim Kaine attacked him,
|
|
KAINE ATTACKED ALLEN OVER DEAL THAT CREATED FAILED SUPER COMMITTEE PRODUCING SEQUESTRATION
Kaine Called Allen’s Position On The Debt Limit Deal “Bad For The Commonwealth.” Also yesterday, Democratic Senate candidate Tim Kaine — who is seeking Webb’s seat next year when Webb retires — held a call with reporters to denounce his Republican opponents’ opposition to the debt deal. . . . That position, Kaine said yesterday, is ‘based on a rigid ideology that’s bad policy and bad for the commonwealth.’” (Chelyen Davis, “Warner, Webb Back Ceiling Bill,” The Free Lance-Star [Fredericksburg, Virginia], 8/3/11)
|
|
“and insists the deal was ‘the right thing to do.’”
|
SUPER: Tim Kaine “Right Thing To Do.” |
KAINE: “THE DEAL WAS THE RIGHT THING TO DO”
Kaine: “The Deal Was The Right Thing To Do.” (Wes Hester, “Allen, Kaine Trade Blows In Virginia Bar Association Debate,” Richmond Times-Dispatch’s Virginia Politics Blog, 7/21/12)
|
|
“George Allen’s plan stops the defense cuts, creates jobs, and grows our economy.
|
|
REPEALING OBAMACARE WILL SAVE TAXPAYERS MORE THAN $1 TRILLION
ObamaCare Costs $2.6 Trillion And Adds $1.7 Trillion In New Spending:
ObamaCare Will Cost $2.6 Trillion Once It Is Fully Implemented. (Office Of The Speaker Of The U.S. House Of Representatives, Report, 1/6/11)
“Between 2013 And 2022, New Entitlement Spending Will Reach $1.7 Trillion Even Though The Main Entitlement Expansions Do Not Launch Until 2014.” (James C. Capretta, “ObamaCare Remains A Budgetary And Policy Disaster,” The Heritage Foundation, Issue Brief #3689, 8/2/12)
“Over A Decade Of Full Implementation, The New Entitlement Spending Will Approach $2 Trillion.” (James C. Capretta, “ObamaCare Remains A Budgetary And Policy Disaster,” The Heritage Foundation, Issue Brief #3689, 8/2/12)
If You Add The $1.7 Trillion In New Spending And The $1 Trillion In New Taxes, Taxpayers Would Save As Much As $2.7 Trillion By Repealing ObamaCare:
“Over The Coming Decade, ObamaCare Taxes Will Reach $1 Trillion, Including New Taxes On Workers’ Wages And Capital Income, As Well As Taxes On Insurers And Manufacturers Of Medical Products.” (James C. Capretta, “ObamaCare Remains A Budgetary And Policy Disaster,” The Heritage Foundation, Issue Brief #3689, 8/2/12)
OBAMACARE WILL ACTUALLY ADD TO THE DEFICIT
Obama Appointee As Trustee For Medicare And Social Security Found ObamaCare Will Actually Add $340 Billion To The Deficit Over 10 Years. “The President Obama’s landmark health-care initiative, long touted as a means to control costs, will actually add more than $340 billion to the nation’s budget woes over the next decade, according to a new study by a Republican member of the board that oversees Medicare financing. The study is set to be released Tuesday by Charles Blahous, a conservative policy analyst whom Obama approved in 2010 as the GOP trustee for Medicare and Social Security. His analysis challenges the conventional wisdom that the health-care law, which calls for an expensive expansion of coverage for the uninsured beginning in 2014, will nonetheless reduce deficits by raising taxes and cutting payments to Medicare providers. (Lori Montgomery, “Health-Care Law Will Add $430 Billion To Deficit, New Study Finds,” The Washington Post, 4/9/12)
House Budget Committee Found $701 Billion Would Be Added To Deficit In The First 10 Years. “According to an analysis by House Budget Committee Republicans, the health care law will cost the nation $2.6 trillion when fully implemented, and add $701 billion to the deficit in its first ten years.” (Office Of The Speaker Of The U.S. House Of Representatives, Report, 1/6/11)
ELIMINATE WASTE FRAUD AND ABUSE IN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
GAO Report Found “Tens Of Billions” Wasted Each Year On Duplicative And Overlapping Efforts. “As lawmakers across the Capitol hear appeals Tuesday from Obama administration secretaries pleading for their budgets, duplication and overlap in dozens of areas of government is wasting ‘tens of billions of dollars annually,’ a new government report shows.” (“Report: Government Wasting ‘Tens Of Billions’ Of Dollars Annually On Duplication, Overlap,” Fox News, 2/28/12)
More Needs To Be Done To Eliminate Waste, Fraud And Abuse Of Medicare And Medicaid As Medicare Made $43 Billion In Improper Payment Last Year And Medicaid $21.9 Billion In Improper Payments, For A Total Of $64.9 Billion In Waste. “In 2011, CMS estimated that Medicaid and Medicare had improper payments of $21.9 billion and almost $43 billion, respectively—among the largest for all federal programs. Both health care programs are on GAO’s list of high-risk programs. Over the years, Congress has passed legislation designed to help address program integrity issues in the two programs but they remain vulnerable to fraud, waste, and abuse. The program integrity challenges are different for Medicaid and Medicare. With 51 distinct state-based programs, Medicaid has complex challenges for finding the appropriate balance between state and federal efforts. Medicare uses contractors to help administer the program and CMS must oversee their efforts.” (“Further Action Needed To Address Vulnerabilities In Medicaid And Medicare Programs,” U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-12-803T, 6/7/12)
OPEN OFFSHORE DRILLING, CREATING JOBS AND NEW REVENUE
George Allen Supports Offshore Drilling For Oil And Natural Gas. By “Opening OCS Planning Areas Can Contribute Trillions Of Dollars In Taxes And Other Public Revenues To Local, State, And Federal Governments.” “Conservative estimates suggest that seven years of initial annual exploration and refining investments would produce approximately $4.8 billion annually in coastal state and local tax revenue and $11.1 billion in U.S. federal tax income. Over thirty years of production, I estimate that the extraction phase of OCS development would yield approximately $561 billion ($18.7 billion per year) in coastal state and local tax revenue and approximately $1.64 trillion ($54.7 billion per year) in new U.S. federal tax income.” (Testimony by Dr. Joseph R. Mason, Professor of Finance at Louisiana State University, before the House Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources, 4/6/11)
Take Advantage Of Onshore Natural Gas, Oil And Coal Reserves In Alaska And Throughout America, From The Appalachians To The West. ANWR Alone Could Bring In $6 Billion For Lease Payments In The First Ten Years. (Federal Assets that Could Be Sold or Leased to Raise Revenue, Letter to Cong. Ron Kind from Congressional Budget Office Director Douglas W. Elmendorf, 3/6/09)
Over The Next 30 Years, At Oil Prices Of $100 A Barrel, Between $84 Billion And $237 Billion In Royalties And Tax Revenue Would Be Generated. (Salvatore Lazzari, “Possible Federal Revenue from Oil Development of ANWR and Nearby Areas,” Congressional Research Service Report RL34547, 6/23/08)
|
|
“Because George Allen knows his job is to fight for ours.”
|